
vs.
Ok guys, this is a battle of the eye makeup removers...in text form...if I have enough Neutrogena left, I will try to remember to do a photo comparing them in one swipe the next time I wear makeup :)
I have FAITHFULLY used the Neutrogena oil-free makeup remover in the blue bottle for the past 2 years (at least, if not more). It's my holy grail for taking off my eye makeup (and honestly, sometimes the rest of my face *gasp*) at the end of the day. It doesn't miss anything and it doesn't leave an uber oil-slick face which is a BIG plus in my mind. I don't even like the feeling of a damp face after you get out of the shower (just to compare...LOL) I also loved that the Neutrogena was a staple for my theatrical makeup class in college. It was strong enough to take off even the cakeiest (is that even a word?) of makeup! So it really stood up to the challenge I have of something that will work both for every day and for my theatrical life. I go for multi-taskers if you haven't noticed.
Alas, moving home to Maine has left me with an almost empty pocket for anything that would be considered an extra. Yes, that means makeup AND remover. And honestly, I really can't afford spend the $6 or $7 on the Neutrogena. Sad as that sounds.
So off to Wal-Mart I trekked tonight to find something that will work just as well for cheaper. I wasn't expecting miracles. My sister had let me borrow her Equate eye makeup remover this past weekend...and it SUCKED! I got it too close to my eyes and I couldn't open them for almost 5 minutes it burned so bad (so as a side tangent: for future reference...do NOT get this one

because it sucks hardcore!)
OBVIOUSLY that meant to me to stay away from Equate removers, but looking at the choices, EVERYTHING that I knew worked how I wanted it to was out of my price range. I was hoping to walk away spending like, $4 at most. Which I wasn't gonna find anywhere. LOL! I kind of knew that though.
But then I found the Equate in the bottle that looks JUST like the Neutrogena one (conveniently located right next to it!) and saw that it was $4 and change. SCORE. (upon reflection, it was probably closer to the $5 side of things) But as I said, I didn't have high hopesfor it because of the last experience....UNTIL JUST A FEW MINUTES AGO!
I absolutely will equate this to the Neutrogena (pun intended?) and can honestly say that in an everyday situation it's just as good! It took almost an entire eye look off in one swipe (and if you have seen my photos, you know I don't use a ton of light colors...LOL)...I had on eyebrow pencil, fluidline, mascara, paintpots, UDPP, you name it and it came off like it was butter melting in a pan. Well, ok, not such a great comparison...but you know what I mean. It doesn't burn if you get it near your eye AND it didn't leave my face all greazzzzzy!!!
So I'm saying this was $5 well spent and I would absolutely recommend this to you all to try if you're looking for cheaper alternatives even to the drugstore name brands :)
Youtube Comparison!
*Disclaimer: I am in no way affiliated with Neutrogena OR Equate and purchased each product independently of each other*